Giants’ Rising Star Abdul Carter Tops NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year Rankings

Abdul Carter, the No. 3 overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft by the New York Giants, is considered a top contender for the NFL Defensive Rookie of the Year award. Many observers regarded him as the premier defensive player in college football last season.

Here’s a breakdown of the situation:

Abdul Carter (New York Giants): As the No. 3 overall pick and a player expected to have a significant role immediately, Carter is the current betting favorite for the award with odds around +250. Playing linebacker, his potential for high sack numbers (even 7-8) from the edge position significantly boosts his candidacy.
Travis Hunter (Jacksonville Jaguars): Selected No. 2 overall by the Jaguars, Hunter is a unique two-way player (cornerback and wide receiver). While incredibly talented and the 2024 Heisman Trophy winner, his odds for Defensive Rookie of the Year are around +750. Cornerbacks have won this award nine times in the past, but his two-way role might dilute his defensive stats compared to a player focused solely on defense.
Jalon Walker (Atlanta Falcons): Drafted at No. 15 overall by the Falcons as an outside linebacker/defensive end, Walker is also considered a strong contender with odds around +900. His versatility and pass-rushing abilities could make him a significant defensive presence.
Mike Green (Baltimore Ravens): A second-round pick (No. 59 overall), Green is an outside linebacker who led the FBS with 17 sacks in his final college season. His odds are around +1200, making him a dark horse to watch, especially if he gets significant playing time.
Will Johnson (Arizona Cardinals): Selected in the second round (No. 47 overall) as a cornerback, Johnson was projected by some as a first-round pick. His odds are longer, around +3000. While cornerbacks can win this award, his second-round status and the fact that he plays a position that doesn’t always accumulate high sack numbers might make it tougher.
Historically, linebackers and defensive ends have frequently won the Defensive Rookie of the Year award. Recent winners include Jared Verse (Defensive End, Los Angeles Rams, 2024), Will Anderson Jr. (Defensive End, Houston Texans, 2023), and Sauce Gardner (Cornerback, New York Jets, 2022).

Carter’s high draft position, the Giants’ need for a strong pass rusher, and the expectation of immediate impact make him a logical favorite. However, the talent of players like Hunter and Walker, and the potential for a high sack season from Green, mean the race could be exciting.